## [Spain: Dismissals that do not comply with what is known as the “dismissal ban” during the pandemic are not automatically null and void](/pt/en_GB/new/spain-dismissals-do-not-comply-what-known-dismissal-ban-during-pandemic-are-not-automatically)
# Spain: Dismissals that do not comply with what is known as the “dismissal ban” during the pandemic are not automatically null and void
Spain - 10 / 20 / 2022
Spain Labor and Employment Alert
-
- [](https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite/?url=https://www.garrigues.com/pt/en_GB/new/spain-dismissals-do-not-comply-what-known-dismissal-ban-during-pandemic-are-not-automatically)
- []()
- []()
Previous Next
**The Supreme Court has issued a** [**press release**](https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/es/Poder-Judicial/Noticias-Judiciales/El-Tribunal-Supremo-descarta-la-nulidad-automatica-del-despido-acordado-sin-causa-valida-durante-la-pandemia-) **reporting that the Plenary Session of the Labor Chamber has handed down a judgment on what is commonly known as the “dismissal ban” under article 2 of** [**Royal Decree-Law 9/2020**](https://www.boe.es/buscar/doc.php?id=BOE-A-2020-4152)**, in the context of the COVID-19 health crisis. The judgment concluded that a dismissal that took place other than as provided in that law should not be classed as null and void.**
The Supreme Court judgment was delivered in a cassation appeal for a definitive ruling on a point of law, led by Garrigues lawyers.
The labor court that heard the case at first instance had declared the dismissal to be unjustified.
Following an appeal by the worker to the Labor Chamber of the Basque Country High Court, the high court held the dismissal to be null and void, following the stance taken in other prior court proceedings.
With its recent judgment, the plenary session of the Labor Chamber of the Supreme Court has now settled a legal debate which has had a broad impact on legal theory and case law since the beginning of the pandemic.
[The Supreme Court press release](https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/es/Poder-Judicial/Noticias-Judiciales/El-Tribunal-Supremo-descarta-la-nulidad-automatica-del-despido-acordado-sin-causa-valida-durante-la-pandemia-) states as follows:
“The judgment, the wording of which will be released in the next few days, concludes that the dismissal in disregard of the provisions of that law should not be classified as null and void unless there is a specific justification for doing so (breach of a fundamental right, evasion of procedural rules on collective dismissals, a personal circumstance that warrants special protection). The following reasoning is given:
**1)** The law itself does not contain a true prohibition, nor do the consequences of a fraudulent dismissal entail its nullity, unless there is an express legislative provision in this regard (as occurs in the case of evasion of collective dismissal procedures). Likewise, using measures as record of temporary employment regulation is not set out as a true obligation.
**2)** Classifying the dismissal as null and void is ruled out because the provisions on the subject (in both the Workers’ Statute and the Labor Jurisdiction Law) disregard the case of fraud (except for dismissals carried out “in stages” to evade collective dismissal procedures).
**3)** Where a contractual termination has been agreed by the company without a valid reason, it should be classified in accordance with the labor legislation in force, both in view of the intricacies of this area of the law and by reference from article 6.3 of the Civil Code (which classifies acts contrary to mandatory legal rules or prohibitions as null and void, “unless such rules or prohibitions provide otherwise in the event of breach”)”.
[Labor and Employment Law](/pt/en_GB/tags/labor-and-employment-law), [Spain](/pt/en_GB/tags/spain)
---
This publication is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or advice of any other kind. It does not seek to offer a comprehensive summary of the legislation and developments to which it refers nor to cover all published material, but rather to provide an overview of selected topics. It is therefore recommended that the official texts be consulted and specific professional advice be sought. Garrigues does not accept any liability for the use made of this information and assumes no obligation to update it after publication.
---
### Contact
[Rosa Zarza](/pt/en_GB/team/rosa-zarza-jimeno)
[Contact]()
- +34 91 514 52 00
[Madrid](https://www.garrigues.com/pt/en_GB/office/madrid)
[Find more professionals](../team)
### Related services
- [Labor and Employment ](/pt/en_GB/services/labor-and-employment)
-
## Find a publication
Select service Administrative and Constitutional Law Agribusiness and Food Automotive Banking and Finance Corporate and M&A Criminal Law and Internal Investigations Data Economy, Privacy and Cybersecurity Dispute Resolution: Litigation and Arbitration Energy EU and Antitrust Law Family Business Fashion Law Financial Regulation Human Capital Services Infrastructure Insurance Intellectual Property Labor and Employment Life Sciences and Healthcare Media and Entertainment Planning, Zoning and Environment Private Equity Real Estate Restructuring and Insolvency Securities Markets Sports Startups & Open innovation Sustainability Tax Technology, Communications and Digital Tourism and Hotels Transport, Logistics and Shipping Facet Services detail Facet Services detail
Select type of content Publications Newsletters Garrigues collection Laws: amendments at a glance News Facet Publication type detail Facet Publication type detail
Min
Max
## News search engine